Quartz vs Granite Countertops: What Is Better for Your Kitchen
June 24, 2023

Quartz vs Granite Countertops: What Is Better for Your Kitchen

Quartz vs granite countertops is a choice many homeowners face. You may have narrowed your choices down to two options: quartz and granite countertops. This guide compares the two. Below we cover what to expect from each material on durability, hygiene, maintenance, appearance, and price, with the pros and cons of each.

Once quartz is the decision, our guide to quartz countertop colors covers which shades suit which cabinets and what each price tier includes.

Whichever material you pick, the edge profile is a separate decision. Our guide to countertop edge profiles covers what changes between engineered quartz and natural stone.

Whichever material you choose, the fitting sequence is nearly identical. Our guide to granite countertop installation compares what changes between granite and quartz at selection, seaming and sealing.

The comparison narrows further inside a single color family. For black specifically, our guide to black quartz versus black granite counters puts sealing, heat tolerance and available finishes side by side.

If granite is winning the comparison, the next step is color. Our granite countertop colors guide lists every family with installed pricing, and explains why granite color varies slab to slab while quartz does not.

If the reason quartz is on your list is that you want the look of marble without the upkeep, start with our guide to quartz that looks like marble, which compares the four marble patterns quartz copies and what each one costs installed.

Once you have settled on quartz, the next decision is brand and series. Our guide to Cambria quartz countertops explains how Design Series, not square footage, sets your price.

If quartz is winning the argument for your kitchen, our Caesarstone countertops guide shows how one brand now spans quartz, porcelain and mineral surfaces with different slab sizes.

Once you have settled on quartz, the next decision is the brand. Our MSI quartz countertops guide and Caesarstone guide cover the two largest ranges we stock.

If quartz wins for your kitchen, the next decision is the brand. Our Silestone countertops guide covers 83 colors, the low-silica Hybriq+ composition and what a Silestone job costs in North Jersey.

Quartz vs Granite Countertops: Engineered Stone vs Natural Stone

Both quartz and granite look good in any home and can add to its value. Both are durable, sanitary, low maintenance, and versatile, with many designs, colors, and pattern options. Each also has its own strengths and downsides. Both suit a new home or a remodel. https://youtu.be/DeVtT4IJe_Q However, your preference in style, appearance, benefits, and features will determine your choice. Knowing what you need in your kitchen makes the decision easier. For some, the choice between quartz vs granite countertops comes down to differences implied by their origin. Natural granite and engineered quartz bring different qualities to your kitchen. Quartz countertops are made of crushed quartz (93%) mixed with a resin binder and color additives. Quartz countertops feature a wide variety of colors, patterns, and styles. Often, they imitate natural stone such as granite or marble. Quartz countertops are consistent from slab to slab, which gives a streamlined, simple look. Large granite and quartz collections, for example MSI Countertops, offer many options, including a wide range of Granite Countertop Colors. Granite countertops are 100% unique and one-of-a-kind. This material is mined in single, large slabs from quarries all around the world. Professionals cut these granite slabs down to manageable sizes and then polish them to a fine finish. Choose granite if you want a slab that no one else has. No two slabs of granite are alike, and even its natural imperfections are part of the look.

Quartz vs Granite Countertops: Durability

Both quartz and granite are durable, long-lasting countertop surfaces. Here is how they compare on durability.

Granite Countertops Durability

Granite has a holocrystalline structure. Instead of developing on their own, the crystals grow into each other. The resulting interlocking structure makes granite very durable. Granite is hard to scratch and heat resistant, so it can last for many years. Granite is so hard that it can dull knife blades. It can even be used outdoors because of its ability to withstand freezing temperatures as well as sun. Granite does not fade or weather outside. However, granite has a porous nature, so some staining is possible if you leave spilled liquids to sit. High-impact blows can also damage granite countertops. If your heart is set on granite but you're worried about its resistance to liquids and stains, make sure to seal your granite correctly and regularly by a professional. This is how you make sure your granite countertops stay stain and liquids-resistant. One example is Typhoon Bordeaux Granite.

Quartz Countertops Durability

Quartz countertops are man-made with a specific use in mind, which makes them harder and more durable than granite countertops. Quartz countertops don't need sealing. Made of ninety-three percent natural quartz stone and seven percent resin, they are scratch-resistant and very hard to damage. Quartz countertops aren't porous, so they are easy to maintain and keep clean. Quartz is not heatproof, though. Excessive heat and hot pots and pans can damage your quartz countertop. If your heart is set on a quartz countertop but you're worried about its resistance to heat, make sure to use trivets and pads for hot pots and pans at all times. This goes for all types of quartz surfaces, even White Quartz Countertops. How to Choose the Right Kitchen Countertop Materials? One way is to explore Pental Quartz and Silestone Quartz Countertops options, and compare them to Caesarstone and MSI, for example.

Quartz vs Granite Countertops Hygiene Comparison

Both granite and quartz are safe for your health if you clean them and take care of them correctly. However, each stone has some specific characteristics in this area as well.

Sealed Granite

If sealed, granite does not harbor bacteria. Cleaning it is simple and doesn’t require lots of effort, and regular cleaning keeps the kitchen free from mold and odors.

Sanitary Quartz

Quartz is created to be non-porous and it is also bacteria-resistant. Cleaning it is as simple as wiping with soap and warm water. In this respect, sealed granite and quartz are equally simple and sanitary. Learn How to Match Backsplash with Granite Countertops.

Quartz vs Granite Countertops Maintenance Comparison

Both quartz and granite won't require lots of cleaning and care. The one difference is that granite needs to be sealed regularly, which is simple to do, although best left to a professional.

Low-Maintenance Granite

Granite countertops are very low maintenance. They rarely need repairs. If anything happens, repairs for granite are relatively easy. Granite countertops do have to be sealed, on a regular basis. With this small effort, they stay in good condition. To keep your granite clean, clean it daily using soap or a mild household cleaner and warm water. Never use abrasive cleaners, acids, and oils as they can stain granite. Every year, make sure to reseal your granite countertops as this will protect them from absorbing wine, lemon juice, and tomato spills. Sealing is the main way to prevent stains. Granite that is not sealed properly can hold bacteria.

Easy to Clean Quartz

Quartz is also easy to maintain. It is naturally bacteria-resistant. Quartz does not require sealing or any other routine maintenance to resist wear and tear for years. However, you shouldn't let spills sit on quartz countertops either. Wipe them down as soon as possible. Quartz countertops maintenance routine includes daily use of soap or a mild household cleaner and warm water. Quartz doesn't need sealing because it has a solid, non-porous surface. Many homeowners choose quartz for its ability to handle coffee, juice, tomato, wine, and oil spills. You can be more relaxed with quartz, but you should still remove spills as soon as possible. Also, have in mind that quartz countertops can feature various finishes and some, like leather or concrete finishes will require more maintenance and care. For example, Calacatta Quartz and Carrara Quartz are easier options because they usually come in a polished finish.

Quartz vs Granite Countertops Appearance Comparison

Quartz and granite look very different, and both have their strong points. If you love a uniform, streamlined look, you'll love quartz countertops. If you prefer a one-of-a-kind look, choose granite countertops. Explore the options each offers below.

One-of-a-Kind Granite

Each granite slab is different and unique, so choose granite if you want many choices and a one-of-a-kind countertop. Granite is formed after the processes of cooling and solidifying molten materials are done. These natural processes give granite a huge range of patterns, colors, and hues. You can find subtle slabs for the whole kitchen or a striking slab for the island, in a wide variety of colors, patterns, veining, and swirls. Granite colors range from black and gray to white, and even orange and red. If you're looking to complement the traditional style of your kitchen, look for brown, green, and burgundy granite color options. In case you prefer modern, minimalist style kitchens, but still want a unique slab, look into white granite types. They are never plain white the way quartz can be, and they work in a contemporary kitchen. Black Granite Countertops are also worth exploring.

Custom Quartz

Quartz is manufactured synthetically. This means that coloring is included in the process. Quartz countertops are far more consistent than granite countertops. At times, slabs can even be made to order with the exact texture, color, and pattern that you want. The main benefit here is the control this gives to the homeowner. Quartz countertops come in many options, from solid colors to nature-imitating slabs, like quartz that looks like marble and granite-looking quartz countertops. This natural look is possible thanks to the process of crushing and blending quartz with resin or some other binding agent. The result is quartz that can look like natural granite. Cambria, Caesarstone colors, and Silestone quartz countertops offer many options. Their range of colors and patterns gives homeowners and kitchen designers a lot to choose from. The appearance of quartz is one of the main reasons why it is so popular nowadays. It gives the look of stone while letting you customize its design and style. Since there is a limited number of quartz countertop design options, choosing the right quartz slabs for your kitchen is much easier than choosing from an endless array of granite slabs.

Quartz vs Granite Countertops Price Comparison

In general, granite is more affordable than quartz. The prices are lower for widely available options. Special quartz finishes and highly exotic granite slabs come with a higher price tag.

Granite Countertops Prices

The more available and common granite countertop slab design, the more affordable the price it will have. Because maintenance is low, affordable granite stays an economical choice over the life of the countertop. However, granite countertops have a wide range of prices. According to HomeAdvisor, the average cost of granite with installation goes from $2,000 to $4,000. Some other sources say that granite price is between about $80 and $175 or even higher for an exotic slab. Granite countertops at Aqua Kitchen and Bath Design Center start at $49 per square foot installed for a single slab deal and go up to $69 per square foot with installation. The cheaper deal includes free sink cut-out, free estimate, and installation, and offers leftover slabs. Other deals include free installation, free estimate, free fabrication and edge treatment, free sealer treatment, and a free stainless kitchen sink.

Quartz Countertops Prices

How expensive are quartz countertops compared to granite? Quartz countertops cost a bit more than granite because they are artificial and man-made. Manufacturers of quartz control the prices of quartz countertops which is different than what fabricators do dealing with raw granite material. According to HomeAdvisor, purchasing and installing quartz countertops costs on average costs between about $70 and $100 per square foot. The price of quartz countertops at Aqua Kitchen and Bath Design Center here in Wayne, NJ comes in three tiers: $49, $59, and $69 per square foot. These prices are for one slab only and may differ if more than one slab is needed. Before investing in either quartz or granite, make sure to inspect and compare the fabrication, installation, and sealing costs. Often, these prices will be included, but sometimes they are not and can increase the overall cost significantly. Exploring our Quartz Countertop products will give you a good idea of how the prices go.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which one is better, granite or quartz? To decide between granite and quartz, first think about what you need, what you like, and what is important to you. Granite is always one of a kind, completely unique, hard, resilient, and durable, and needs a bit more maintenance than quartz. On the other side, quartz stone countertop material is fabricated, and man-made for hardworking use and active kitchens. Quartz is even harder than granite and more durable. It lasts a long time when used within the manufacturer's recommendations. It's non-porous and very resilient. Consequently, it will need less maintenance and upkeep than granite. However, the look of quartz is uniform and although it imitates natural stones, it comes in well-established colors and designs. Is quartz more expensive than granite? Currently, granite is more expensive than quartz in general. However, it depends on the type of granite or quartz you're looking at. Pure white quartz is less expensive than black quartz while some types of black quartz may be more expensive than some granite stones. Generally, on both sides, there are more expensive and less expensive options. For example, white granite is more expensive than granite in brown and earth tones simply because the traditional granite options are not as trendy as they used to be and white granite options are. Also, many other factors will influence the total price: the finishing, edge design, bookmatching if needed, etc. What's the difference between granite and quartz? The main difference between granite and quartz is that granite is a 100 percent naturally sourced stone while quartz is an engineered material made by man. Quartz-engineered stone has about 95% natural quartz stone and 5% manmade materials such as pigments and various resins. Granite is a completely natural stone, formed by natural processes. Man only cuts and polishes granite, creating slabs of different sizes for various uses in kitchens, baths, and for other applications in residential and commercial projects. Which is easier to care for and maintain, granite or quartz? Although every granite countertop is unique, it is easier to take care of and maintain quartz. Granite countertops require sealing at least once a year, for which you need professional help in order to do it right. You won't need professional help only if you are an experienced DIYer. Granite also needs special care in maintenance as harsh cleaners can damage them. On the other hand, quartz is easy to maintain because it is non-porous, resists stains, and needs very little care. Does quartz scratch more easily than granite? Granite scratches more easily than quartz. Quartz is engineered to last, and its hardness gives it good scratch resistance. Quartz is also less likely than granite to crack or chip. To make granite durable and resistant like quartz you will need to seal it regularly. At the same time, quartz offers these benefits without additional maintenance or care. Is granite more shiny than quartz? Polished varieties of granite and quartz are very shiny. On the other hand, non-polished finishes for granite and quartz, like leathered, suede, or velluto finish, are less shiny. If you like your countertop stone to look shiny, choose the polished finish. Besides the sparkly and shiny look it gives to the stone surfaces, polished finish also makes it easier to remove stains from the stone, if staining occurs. Still, being natural stone, granite will always be shinier than quartz. Does granite stain more than quartz? Granite is a natural stone that stains more easily than man-made quartz. Quartz is created to be resistant to staining, as kitchens are the places where the usage of liquids is likely to cause stains. This makes it a popular kitchen countertop. The difference comes from the resins that are included within the quartz material. These resins make the stone less porous and more stain resistant than granite.

What Should I Choose: Quartz or Granite?

Both quartz and granite make good kitchen countertops. Your needs, habits, and style preferences decide which one fits. Most people get a few or only one chance at thoroughly remodeling their home and kitchen, so naturally, they want to get it right. If you have a busy lifestyle, and love the minimalist or simple, streamlined look, go with quartz countertops. But if you love to have something that no one else has, look into many options granite countertops offer. Either one will last for years and is easy to maintain. Here at Aqua Kitchen and Bath Design Center in Wayne, NJ, we will encourage you to choose what you love and what will suit your unique needs best. Our 8000 sqft indoor and outdoor showroom and our designers can make the selection easier. We carry over 100 granite colors and many varieties of quartz countertops in stock. Contact us to get a free estimate on quartz or granite countertops.

Share