Installing New Kitchen Cabinets in an Older Home: What to Expect
Expect the installers to spend more time on layout and shimming than on hanging boxes. In an older house the floor slopes, the walls lean and the corners have drifted away from 90 degrees, while a cabinet is a rigid, square box that has to end up level so the doors line up and the countertop sits flat. The difference is made up with shims, scribed panels and filler strips, and most of that work is planned before the order is placed.
Older North Jersey houses add a few more items to the list: plaster over lath, soffits with unknown contents, radiators on the cabinet wall and paint that may contain lead. None of them stops a kitchen project. Each one should be found before the cabinets are ordered, because that is when the fix costs the least.
Floors that are out of level
Base cabinets are set level regardless of what the floor does. Installers find the highest point of the floor along the cabinet run and start there. Every other box is raised on shims until its top meets the same level line, so the countertop has one flat plane to sit on.
That has visible consequences. At the low end of the room the gap under the cabinets grows, and the toe kick has to be cut taller or tapered to cover it. Counter height is fixed at the high point, so the counter stands a little higher off the floor at the low end. The dishwasher and range openings need to be checked against the floor where those appliances will sit, since their adjustable feet have a limited range.
A slope the shims can absorb is routine. A floor that drops sharply across the run, or flexes when you walk on it, is a subfloor or framing question for a contractor to settle first, because any correction changes every finished height in the room. If new flooring is part of the project, decide whether the floor goes down before or after the cabinets before anyone measures for toe kicks.
Walls that lean, bow or wave
Cabinets are screwed to the wall framing through a rail at the back of each box. If the wall bows and the installer pulls the screws tight anyway, the box twists, and a twisted box shows up as doors that will not sit even. So the installer shims behind the cabinet wherever the wall falls away and fastens through the shim.
The gap that remains between the cabinet side and the wall is closed in one of two ways. A scribe molding is a thin strip that bends to follow the wall. A scribed panel or filler is cut on site so its edge matches the wall's contour exactly. Corners get the same treatment. The designer leaves a filler strip between the last cabinet and the adjoining wall, and the installer trims it to a taper if the corner is out of square.
The trade-off is that an old room needs wider fillers than a new one. A layout that runs cabinets tight from wall to wall with no filler depends on walls that are true, and it is the wrong plan for a house where they are not. Tall pantry and oven cabinets deserve extra attention, because a full-height box beside a leaning wall shows the lean along its whole side unless a scribed panel covers it.
Plaster, lath and finding something solid
Plaster over wood lath is thicker and more brittle than drywall. It can crack or let go of the lath when old cabinets are pulled off, and it will not hold a loaded wall cabinet by itself. Every cabinet has to be fastened into framing behind the plaster.
Stud spacing in older walls is often irregular, so installers locate each stud individually instead of assuming a pattern. Where a stud is missing at the spot a cabinet needs one, a carpenter adds blocking while the wall is open. The same goes for whatever the old cabinets were hiding, such as unfinished patches, abandoned pipe holes or layers of wallpaper. If the new layout exposes that wall, it needs patching before install day.
Opening a wall can also reveal wiring or plumbing that is not up to current standards. That work belongs to a licensed electrician or plumber, and it may bring the project under your town's permit process. Our overview of kitchen permits in New Jersey explains who decides.
Soffits, radiators and other things that stay put
A soffit above the old wall cabinets may hide a duct, a drain from the bathroom upstairs or nothing at all. Have someone cut a small inspection hole before the wall cabinet heights are final. An empty soffit can come out, which opens the wall for taller cabinets. A soffit with a pipe in it stays unless a plumber reroutes the pipe, and the cabinets are sized to finish under it, a situation covered in our piece on cabinet design for low ceilings.
A steam or hot-water radiator on a cabinet wall takes up floor space a base cabinet would otherwise use. You can design around it with a shorter run or an open section, or have a heating contractor move it or replace it with a different kind of heater. Moving it is not cabinet work, and it has to be finished before the cabinet order is final. Ask the designer what clearance the cabinet manufacturer wants beside a heat source, since finishes react to sustained heat.
Window sills deserve the same early look. A sill that sits below counter height means the countertop cannot pass under the window without changing the window, the sill or the layout.
Paint from before 1978
The federal government banned lead-based paint for use in homes in 1978, and the Environmental Protection Agency warns that renovation work in a pre-1978 home that has lead-based paint can create hazardous lead dust. Under the agency's Renovation, Repair and Painting Rule, anyone paid to do work that disturbs painted surfaces in such a home must be certified, with workers trained in lead-safe practices.
Removing old cabinets, cutting out a soffit and opening plaster all disturb paint. The rule generally does not apply to homeowners doing the work in their own house, though the EPA still recommends hiring a lead-safe certified contractor, and it does apply if you rent out all or part of the home. Before demolition starts, ask the firm doing it for its lead-safe certification.
Questions owners of older homes ask
Do the walls have to be replaced with drywall first?
No. Cabinets fasten through sound plaster into the studs. Walls are opened only where plumbing or wiring is moving, where blocking is needed, or where the plaster has come loose from the lath.
Can the new cabinets follow the old layout exactly?
Usually, and keeping the sink and range where they are avoids plumbing and gas changes. Individual cabinet widths may still change, because the new boxes are sized to today's appliance openings and to the fillers an out-of-square room needs.
Will gaps open after the first winter?
Hairline movement is normal. New Jersey summers are humid and heated winter air is dry, so wood framing, floors and cabinet parts swell and shrink through the year, and a caulked scribe joint can show a fine line in January that closes by July. Our guide to cabinets and seasonal humidity explains what is normal and what is not.
Have the room looked at before you pick a door style
In an older house, the conditions in the room shape the order as much as the finish does. An in-home appointment with Aqua Kitchen lets the room itself be looked at, so a sloped floor, a soffit or a radiator can be planned around from the start. Our own crews install the cabinets we sell, which includes leveling the boxes, joining the runs, hanging the doors and setting fillers and trim. You can compare cabinet lines and finishes online beforehand, and our step-by-step remodeling guide shows where cabinet installation falls among the other trades.
